Friday, 26 January 2007

USA (North Carolina) Marcus Reymond Robinson (m), black,

- From Amnesty International USA

To read the current Urgent Action newsletter, go to

We need 500,000 signatures to change America's
course on human rights. Please sign AIUSA's ''America
I Believe In'' pledge now and if you already have, tell
your friends and family to do the same. Visit

26 January 2007

Further information on UA 14/07 (18 January 2007) – Death
penalty / Legal concern

USA (North Carolina) Marcus Reymond Robinson (m), black,
aged 33

On 25 January 2007 in Raleigh, North Carolina, Wake County
Superior Court Judge Donald Stephens blocked the execution
of Marcus Robinson, who was scheduled to be put to death at
2am local time on 26 January. He was sentenced to death in
1994 for a murder committed when he had just turned 18 years

Judge Stephens' order followed an appeal filed by lawyers
for Marcus Robinson and fellow death row inmate James Thomas
(see UA 18/07, 24 January, Their
petition for injunctive relief cited a decision taken by the
North Carolina Medical Board on 17 January 2007 prohibiting
doctors from participating in executions in the state. Under
the terms of the decision, medical professionals would not
be disciplined for being present at an execution, but are
prohibited from administering the lethal drugs or assisting
with the execution. The lawyers argued that the absence of a
physician monitoring and supervising the condemned
prisoner's medical condition created the risk that the
execution would cause pain and suffering that would violate
the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

Following a hearing, Judge Stephens noted that the state
correctional authorities had not challenged the legal
authority of the Medical Board to prohibit the participation
of doctors in executions. He also noted that the authorities
had chosen to comply with the Medical Board's decision so
that physicians would no longer directly participate in
executions. According to Judge Stephens' order, the
correctional authorities have said that ''although a
physician will be present during an execution, that
physician will not supervise or participate in the injection
of any drugs or the monitoring of the prisoner's medical
condition''. The state further asserted that its current
execution procedures could be lawfully carried out without
the participation of a physician, but rather by using other
trained personnel.

Judge Stephens noted that the state's current position
differed from the position taken in previous executions, and
that the change was ''significant''. However, he further
noted that this change in execution protocol had only been
approved by the Secretary of Corrections and the Warden of
Central Prison (where death row is housed). The judge wrote:
''The court is of the opinion that the Secretary of
Corrections and the Warden may not significantly alter the
existing protocol for the manner and method of executions,
which protocol has previously received court approval as
constitutional, without first submitting such substantial
changes to the Governor and the Council of State for review
and approval.'' Without such approval, Judge Stephens wrote,
the execution would violate state law. (The Council of State
is made up of elected members of the cabinet: the Lieutenant
Governor, the Secretary of State Elaine Marshall, the
Attorney General, the Commissioner of Agriculture, the
Commissioner of Insurance, the Commissioner of Labor, the

Superintendent of Public Instruction, the State Treasurer,
and the State Auditor).

As a result of the order, Marcus Robinson's stay of
execution is indefinite, and executions in North Carolina
are effectively on hold. This follows the recent de facto
moratoriums on executions in Florida and California while
the authorities attempt to ''fix'' their lethal injection
protocols (see USA: New Year's resolution: End a cruel and
outdated punishment, December 2006,
In six other states — Arkansas, Delaware, Maryland,
Missouri, Ohio and South Dakota — almost all executions are
being stayed by the courts in the face of lawsuits
challenging lethal injection procedures. In Illinois and New
Jersey there are formal moratoriums on executions. In New
Jersey, a study commission set up by the state legislature
has concluded that the death penalty should be abolished
(see New Jersey Death Penalty Study Commission recommends
abolition, 3 January 2007, There
are also other signs that the USA is slowly turning against

capital punishment (see USA: The experiment that failed: A
reflection on 30 years of judicial killing, 16 January 2007,

There is strong public support for a moratorium on
executions in North Carolina. Approximately 1,000 faith
group congregations, businesses and community groups have
passed resolutions calling for a moratorium, including
almost 40 local governments in the state. In addition, more
than 40,000 people in North Carolina have signed the
moratorium petition.

RECOMMENDED ACTION: Please send appeals to arrive as quickly
as possible:
- noting the order issued by Judge Stephens;
- urging the Governor to use this opportunity to support a
full moratorium on executions in North Carolina, noting the
widespread public support for such a measure.

Governor Michael F. Easley
Governor's Office
20301 Mail Services Center
Raleigh, NC 27699-0301, USA
(via website)
Fax: 1 919 733-2120 / 1 919 715-3175
Salutation: Dear Governor

Action Office if sending appeals after 9 March 2007.

Tip of the Month:
You may refer to Amnesty International in your letter,
unless otherwise stated in the case sheet. However,
appeals written in a personal or professional capacity
show the diversity of concern regarding the particular
individual(s) and human rights abuses.

Within the United States:
$0.24 - Postcards
$0.39 - Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
To Mexico and Canada:
$0.55 - Postcards
$0.63 - Airmail Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
$0.75 - Aerogrammes
To all other destination countries:
$0.75 - Postcards
$0.84 - Airmail Letters and Cards (up to 1 oz.)
$0.75 - Aerogrammes

Amnesty International is a worldwide grassroots movement
that promotes and defends human rights.

This Urgent Action may be reposted if kept intact, including
contact information and stop action date (if applicable).
Thank you for your help with this appeal.

Urgent Action Network
Amnesty International USA
600 Pennsylvania Ave SE 5th fl
Washington DC 20003
Phone: 202.544.0200
Fax: 202.675.8566


No comments: