MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD ON APPEAL - Lightbourne

http://www.oranous.com/florida/IanLightbourne/motiontosup.htm

http://www.floridasupremecourt.org/pub_info/summaries/briefs/06/06-2391/Filed_09-21-2007_PetionersMotionToSuppressROA.pdf

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA

IAN DECO LIGHTBOURNE,

Petitioner,

Case No. SC06-2391

v.

BILL McCOLLUM, ET AL.,

Respondents.

____________________________/

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT THE RECORD ON APPEAL

THE PETITIONER, IAN DECO LIGHTBOURNE, by and through undersigned counsel, and pursuant to Fla. R. App. P. 9.200(f), requests that this Court grant this motion to supplement the record. As grounds in support of this motion, Mr. Lightbourne states:

1. By order dated August 6, 2007, the Marion County Clerk’s Office was directed to file the record on appeal by September 14, 2007. During the preparation of the initial brief, Mr. Lightbourne noticed that certain pleadings and documents were missing from the record. Due to the expedited nature of the briefing schedule, Mr. Lightbourne filed his brief on September 19, 2007, before seeking to supplement the record.

2. Mr. Lightbourne requests that the record be supplemented with the following:

1. Notice of Hearing for 12/15/06 (12/14/06).

1. Letter from Barbara Davis, Asst. Attorney General, to the Honorable Carven Angel (12/15/06).
2. Proposed order submitted by State (12/15/06).
3. Transcript of hearing held on 12/15/06.
4. Notice of Filing re: public records requests to the Office of the Medical Examiner (1/11/07).
5. State’s Response to Motion for Disclosure of Favorable Evidence (2/16/07).
6. Notice of Hearing for 2/21/07 (2/14/07).
7. Objection to Demand for Public Records by Office of the Medical Examiner (4/2/07).
8. Order setting Status Conference and Discovery Schedule Concerning Evidentiary Hearing (4/12/07).
9. Motion for Clarification and for a Continuance of the Evidentiary Hearing Scheduled for May 18 and 21, 2007 (4/24/07).
10. State’s Notice of Filing of Fax Transmittal from the ME’s Office (4/24/07).
11. Defendant’s Witness List (4/27/07).
12. State’s witness list (4/27/07).
13. State’s Second Motion in Limine (5/3/07).
14. Notice of Hearing for 5/4/07 (4/30/07).
15. State’s Motion for Order Requiring Exchange of Exhibits (5/2/07).
16. Notice of Hearing for 5/11/07 (5/4/07).
17. Notice of Filing letter from Mr. Lightbourne’s counsel to counsel for DOC (5/7/07).
18. Notice of Hearing re: Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum (5/9/07).

2

1. State’s Notice of Filing re: May 9, 2007 procedures, letter to the Governor, and DOC response (5/9/07).
2. Motion to Quash Subpoena Duces Tecum to Appeal for Hearing to Reporter Ron Word (5/9/07).
3. Notice of Hearing Re: Objection to and Motion to Quash Subpoena (5/11/07).
4. State’s Motion to Quash Subpoena re: Rodriguez (5/8/07).
5. DOC’s Motion to Quash Subpoena for Secondary Executioner (5/10/07).
6. DOC’s Motion to Quash Subpoena for Medically Qualified Execution Team Member #3 (5/10/07).
7. Defendant’s Exhibit List (5/10/07).
8. State’s Exhibit List (5/10/07).
9. Defendant’s Additional Witness List (5/11/07).
10. State’s Notice of Filing re: CV’s for experts (5/10/07).
11. Notice of Supplemental Authority re:
Workman v. Bredesen, et al. (5/9/07).
12. Notice of Hearing re: protective order (5/8/07).
13. Notice of Filing: letter from undersigned counsel to the State (5/15/07).
14. Defendant’s Additional Exhibit List (6/8/07).
15. Notice of Hearing for 6/14/07 (6/6/07).
16. Notice of Hearing for 6/18/07 (6/14/07).
17. Notice of Supplemental Authority re: Florida Attorney General Advisory Opinion (6/21/07).
18. Defendant’s Additional Witness List (6/25/07).
19. Response in Opposition to Defendant’s Motion to Depose State Witness Dr. Kris Sperry (6/27/07).

3

1. Notice of Hearing for 7/16/07 (7/9/07).
2. Notice of Taking Deposition (7/15/07).
3. Defendant’s Additional Witness List (7/12/07).
4. Notice of Filing re: letter and Defendant’s Proposed Order (7/26/07).
5. Notice of Hearing for 8/6/07 (8/2/07).
6. Order setting final hearing for Sept. 5, 2007 (8/2/07).
7. Defendant’s Motion to Depose (8/10/07).
8. Defendant’s Second Motion to Depose (8/14/07).
9. State’s Notice of Filing of order in
State v. Schwab (8/13/07).
10. State’s Notice of Compliance (8/13/07).
11. Defendant’s Additional Witness List (8/17/07).
12. State Witness List (8/17/07).
13. Motion for Immediate Hearing (8/21/07).
14. Notice of Filing of Order in
State v. Pope (8/22/07).
15. State’s Written Closing Memorandum (9/05/07).
16. Notice of Filing re: Dr. Heath notarized affidavit (9/13/07).

3. Mr. Lightbourne has received copies of page 69-199 from Volume I of the Record. It is counsel’s understanding that these pages were included in Volume I that was sent to this Court. If those pages were not included, Mr. Lightbourne also seeks to supplement the record with those additional pages.

4 5

WHEREFORE, Mr. Lightbourne respectfully requests that this Court grant the motion to supplement the record.

Respectfully submitted,

__________________________

SUZANNE MYERS KEFFER

Assistant CCRC

Florida Bar No. 0150177

ROSEANNE ECKERT

Assistant CCRC

Florida Bar No. 082491

ANNA-LIISA NIXON

Staff Attorney

Florida Bar No. 0026283

OFFICE OF THE CAPITAL

COLLATERAL REGIONAL COUNSEL

101 N.E. 3rd Ave., Suite 400

Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301

(954) 713-1284

COUNSEL FOR MR. LIGHTBOURNE

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished by U.S. Mail and facsimile to Kenneth S. Nunnelley, Assistant Attorney General, 444 Seabreeze Blvd, 5th Floor, Daytona Beach, FL 32118, Rock E. Hooker, Assistant State Attorney, 19 NW Pine Avenue, Ocala, FL 34475, on this 21st day of September, 2007.

__________________________

SUZANNE MYERS KEFFER

Assistant CCRC

Florida Bar No. 0150177